Views shared
by several ayurveda professionals and non-ayurveda people in discussion group:
Disclaimer:
All views shared here are only for knowledge. This information doesn’t have any scientific validation. Various doctors and non-medicos have shared their views and experiences in this discussion. Please do not try any of the suggestions described here, without prior consult from your regular, qualified doctor. Dr. Prerak Shah and no other person is responsible for any unwanted effects, side effects or contra-indications in your health. Thank you.
Disclaimer:
All views shared here are only for knowledge. This information doesn’t have any scientific validation. Various doctors and non-medicos have shared their views and experiences in this discussion. Please do not try any of the suggestions described here, without prior consult from your regular, qualified doctor. Dr. Prerak Shah and no other person is responsible for any unwanted effects, side effects or contra-indications in your health. Thank you.
(If
you like this activity, and wants to be a part of this chat discussion on
whatsapp, please send in your request. Whatsapp your name, short intro
to +91-9824243567. Thank you.)
Next topic for discussion: Frozen
shoulder or shoulder pain and restricted movements....#ayurvedic approach...
Dr. Mahavir Patil: "avabahuk"
Dr. Prerak Shah: Yes...Frozen
shoulder is known as 'avabahuk' in ayurveda...
Dr. J. T. Contractor Herbal
Therapist: Aqua therapy gives optimum results,hot water fomentation for 20
minutes on painful part & on spinal cord scull to tail,twice daily, wipe
off with towel, gentle massage with pre-heated til oil made with jaifal (nutmeg)
extract
Dr. Mahavir Patil: why
jaifal (nutmeg)...
Dr. J. T. Contractor Herbal
Therapist: Small pieces of Jaifal to be boiled in pure til oil until
jaifal turn brown black, filter it to store in glass bottle, jaifal & til
oil releases muscle fibers with hot water fomentation.
Dr. Mahavir Patil: but
jaiphal is "stambhak". i want to know, by which gunna ,it act as
musle relaxtant?
Dr. Madhuri Patil Chaudhari: I have used
only Jaiphal with Dry Ginger (lepana) for migrain and trauma-induced headaches
with good results. In Avbahuk ? May be
because it is vedanasthapak- reducing
pain related to nerves
Supra19: Dr.
Can u plz tell me how, how much and when to take jaifal and ginger…For migrain
Dr. Madhuri Patil Chaudhari: A
tsp.of both powders mixed with warm water. Applied when warm. Or Pishtan (
making paste) by rubbing in circles 1/2 cms piece on Sahan ( patla type marbale
or granite stone) with very little and warm water. It is for extetnal
application on forehead everyday @bedtime.
Vd. Kundan Gadhavi: in frozen
shoulder upanah gives verygood results.in both
diabetic or non diabetics.as frozen shoulder is most commonly seen in pt
with diabetes
Vd.vimalben Anand: Agnikarma
shows good results in avabahuk….Nasya therapy can be done in avabahuk with any
vatshamak oil…. Siravedh raktamokshana is also indicated in avabahuk, and
if the posture of patient is incorrect, then first try to correct the posture
by the yoga with the proper breathing
Dr. Prerak Shah: "pain
and restriction of shoulder movement" leaves many questions: Is it bone related? Joint related? Muscle
related? Ligament related? Or neurology related? Is it due to degeneration? Due
to postural problem? Due to trauma? Or injury? For how long Pain remains?
Constant or only with the movements? Is it associated with inflammation or not?
Is it referred pain or not? Does pain radiates from shoulder to any part or
organ? Or does pain radiates from any part to shoulder? If I suggest massage and if the condition is
aamavata or trauma - fracture etc, then it will increase and can be more
serious condition.
Dr. Dipak shirude: I have
experience of some patients presenting as frozen shoulder but finally diagnosed
cardiac illness ( blockages ) and got relieved after successful treatment of
heart.
Vd. Jayesh Thakkar: Frozen
Shoulder or Avabahuka can be due to Diabetes, cervical disease, shoulder
injury, even shoulder surgery or other causes...common symptoms are
pain-stiffness, decrease motion of shoulder...as per scenario we see...cala
guna kshaya...manda, stabdha guna vriddhi...so any treatment which is
vata-kapha hara & usna and is as per nidaan/cause helps……In my clinical
experience have found lepa or potli seka with usna dravya helpful. Simple
poultice of yellow sarso (pilli rai) have found to be very useful &
economical in our apaan desa of Bengal. From my south experience have found
Karpasthyadi Taila nasya very very helpful in high dose of 8drps.
Abha/Trayodasang Guggul is good. Beside this supported exercise, controlling sugar in DM and following
anti Vata diet-lifestyle helps.
Dr.Surendra Davanagere: Panchamruthaloha
gugulu is also useful in this condition
Canada Nitin Shah: I
myself was victim of Tenosynovitis of this area and treated with Vishgarbha oil
application, followed by seating in a steam chamber for 10-15 minutes for a week
and regular practices of neck rotation, shoulder rotation, garudasana,
gomukhasana and now have full shoulder moment. Diabetics are more prone to this
condition and yes, rule out the other causes.
Satyen: Frozen
shoulder is caused due to vatta disorder? Will consuming dry ginger useful?
Dr. Suyog Kulkarni: In
allopathy , now a days sublingual pain killers are given to avoid gastritis as
well as for quick action. Can we think of such route for our medicines ? As far
as I know Hemagarbha , Sootshekhar matra
are examples of such route.
Dr. Madhuri Patil Chaudhari:
'Lehya' can be said to be sublingual route of admiistration.
Dr. Arun Tiwari: Manyastambh,
Grivastambh,vishvachi and Avbahuk are vataj diseases. In Manyastambh involves
shleshma. In Chakradatt Mash ,kevach and Bala in form of decoction use three
months for avbahuk and vishvachi.
Dr. Hardikchandra Kalal: We
should help physiotherapy with Ayurved
for treatment of avbahuk (frozen shoulder). Its give us speedy result.
According to i Ayurved it is yuktikrut vyayam..Specially in frozen shoulder..ll
Vd. Dhruti Nirav Bhatt: In
Avabahuk (Frozen shoulder) Nasya,
Nadiswed and Physiotherapy gives result. Vishtindukvati Dipan pachan aushadh.Pipplimool churna,sunti
churna
Vd. Pankaj Chhayani: Apbahuka
is a major disease come across with daily practise. Vitiated vata situated at
amsamoola(shoulder girdle) causes loss of motor activities or difficulty in
movements of hand and wasting of associated muscle...In case of local symptoms
take important place , as compared to general symptoms: 1) Bahupraspanda hara:
loss/ impaired/ difficult movement of upper limb 2) Amsabandhana shosha: muscle wasting of
shoulder girdle 3) shoola: painful
shoulder
According to modern: 1) gradual
onset of shoulder stiffness 2) pain
manifest after significant shoulder range of movement lost 3) pain well localized to rotator cuff 4) pain inferes with sleep 5) pain radiation into deltoid and anterior
arm.
Inspection:- 1) pt holds arm protectively at side 2) deltoid and supraspinotous atrophy..
There are are some clinical conditions of modern science which may be compared
with that of apabahuka: 1) peri
arthritis or frozen shoulder or adhesive capsulitis
2) sub acromial or sub deltoid bursitis 3) lesion of the rotatory cuff 4) brachial plexus neuropathy 5) OA of shoulder joint 6) incomplete rupture of supraspinatous tendon 7) bicipital tendinitis 8) painful shoulder...
Management of apabahuka is achieved by adopting the treatment measures of
vatavyadhi in general and specific treatment for apabahuka... 1) restricted movement with muscle wasting --
Use various tails, nasya, consume ghee soon after having meal, sasti shali
pinda swedana, jambeer pinda swedana 2)
pain full restricted movement without wasting--- use various gugglu , swedana,
rasa ashaudhi...
Shanku chirag: In some
case patient having psychological
pressure towards responsibility, and become over concern about
responsibility and that leads to freeze the shoulder (Always responsibility we
carry on shoulder) so, counseling of the patient will help if we succeed to
transfer alertness to relaxation
Dr. Arun Tiwari: मेथिका चंद्रशूरश्च कालाजाजी यवानिका….. तत् चूर्णम् भक्षितम् नित्यम् ……….निहन्ति पवनामयं,….अजीर्णम्
शूलं आध्मानम विविधःवात वेदनाः
Dr. J. T. Contractor Herbal
Therapist: Pl gv English name or Hindi
Prof. Siddharth Panchal- L J
Pharmacy: Yellow looks methi (trigonela foenum gracum) seeds, Black-kalijiri
(vernonia anthelmintica) , Reddish- looks lepidium and Brown is Ajvain
Supra16: what
is this recipe and benefits? Pls share
Vd Charu Trivedi: Its
chaturbjj
Vd. Ritaben Nadiad: Methi
, asheriyo , kalijiri and ajmo….It is usefull in all type vataj pain
Surat Vd Mukul Patel: Regarding frozen
shoulder, I think we are missing out
something important. This condition
is associated with Certain systemic
diseases. For example , a significant
number of patients suffering from
frozen shoulder are seen to be suffering from diabetes
or hypothyroidism.….Sometimes it
so happens that the diagnosis of these
major disease is done when a patient
comes to the clinician. …….Besides, this is a self limiting condition. In the first phase there is pain n
rigidity, after 6to 10months the pain
intensity subsides while the rigidity
/restriction in movement remains, which decreases after some months. Physiotherapy does help. Ayurveda prescribes swimming. Effectiveness of drugs (any drugs) is questionable,
it is a matter which research, since pain vanishes by itself after some months. This is the natural course of the diseases.
Dr. Prerak Shah: I agree.
This is our western thinking process, that on hearing of the symptom or
complain, we start recommending medicines, without going in the depth of
diagnosis. For some extent it might be helpful but for in longer run it may be
harmful for Ayurveda
Dr. Ravindra Upadhyay: Dhanvantara
tailam. massage, followed by Nadisweda of Dashmoolkwatha, Mahayograj Guggul 2
tds, Ekang vir ras, 1tds, Dashmool kwatha, 60 ml twice. Avoid. Curds,
Tomato, freezed food, physiotherapy.
Rajal shukla: Pain and
swelling of any area of body….Gugal, erandmool , Punarnava , Patala. Bhoy
aambali Bhoy ringani gokharu, Galo satva, Bhavna - Dashmool qwath
OPD Vd Daxa Patel: Systematic
nasya is best treatment of frozen shoulder
Vd. Gaurang darji: Restriction
of any joint should be due to vaayu..So any vaat nashak treatment should be
given...Abhyang+swedan local along with matra basti...Vish tinduk vati…Palsinuron......Kshir
bala tail capsules..Or sneh paan…Agnikarm can give dramatic result…Exercise
daily minimum 25-30 min…In physio they give some local shock therapy it also
works...Or baajri upnah..or patra pind swed/ upnaah...
Vaat nashak diet..Shigru soup...Udad daal...Garam paani no shek...
IPR Chhayaben: So many
medicine !! Pl say one or two.. People like us, non medico n patient, need specific thing..
Gaurang darji: Its due to
various type of condition of disease...For non medico..Daily massage,steam,and
exercise is advisable...
Dr. Prerak Shah: There is no
short cut. We don't have pain killers like western medicine. Pt need to go
personally with Ayu doc to get final diagnosis and final treatment suggestions.
Dr. Ravindra Upadhyay: treatment
varies from pt to pt, pt not having any movement of the shoulder with
uncontrolled DM, needs to control sugar first, post traumatic immobillisation
of the jt gives rise to frozen shoulder, needs to mobilise it regularly, pain
is overcome with regular passive rhythmic movement of the affected and non
affected joints, drugs alone whether Ayurvedic, Allopathic, Homeopathic alone
can not give desired results.
Vd. Krup Vasavada: For Frozen
Shoulder Agnikarma has shown Wonderful results within short time ....For Pain
and Stiffness It's the Best treatment ....
Vd. Pankaj Chhayani: If pain is due
to Nerve problem then use ashwagandha and various oil in abhayanga and
internally
Vd. nikul patel: Abyang
swedan is 10 times more faster than Physiotherapy treatment.. truly experience
in lots of patients
Shri Minoo parabia: We
recommend Aswagandha 2tds for a month
Vd. Dipam Tripathi: Ashwagandha...good….Patrpind
swed is also work v.good..Nasya ..also good
Dr Dipak Shirude: ||
Frozen shoulder || Find of cause is also very important for a successful
chikitsa. If someone is typing and typing for whatsapp ( and that too without
any benefit ), and a Vaidya is providing him best treatment, it is difficult to
cure him. The above was just an example. There are so many things in frozen
shoulder like driving faulty posture, work habits etc…….The prognosis and treatment
depends on the exact site of sthaan-sanshray. ……If the vaat is resided into the
superficial places of the shoulder joint ( upto skin and musculature ), we can
surely cure the ailment within seconds by Agnikarma and that too for permanent.
……..But, although it is rare, if the vaat dosha is sited deep into the bony
structures and ligaments stuck to bones, and it has disturbed the anatomy of
the joint like necrosis or something like that, it becomes difficult to cure
with Agnikarma. This situation needs ample efforts. ……..Snehan swedan,
especially Rooksha swed by sand or crude salt pottali……Patrapottali including
castor oil and annalepam also better option in some difficult cases……Nasya with
warm ksheerbala or plain sesame oil, done regularly is useful to prevent and
cure as well as to avoid recurrence i.e. apunarbhav……Regular and specific
Vyaayaam i.e. physiotherapy…..Asthiposhak as well as aampaachak internal
medicines are required…..Oils having antispasmodic action are better. Prasaranyaadi
quath is worth to mention in this post.
Vd. Kinshuk Hirpara: In
frozen shoulder particularly massage with nirgundi oil or mahanarayan oil a bit
warm, is beneficial. In medicine,
agnitundi vati is a very good option as pain reliever too. Rest for 5
days then light exercises preferred but it's upto patient's pain and other
conditions
Vd. Kinshuk Hirpara: Yes,
it might be just a symptom of vitiated Doshas. So its beneficial to go for deep
history of the patient may be he might have simply history of having stale food
(frozen type of) for long time. So all digestive system vitiated and bcz of
that stiffness of different body parts can be occurred….Also observed in
patients, many patients of low blood
pressure also having this prob of frozen shoulder. So line of treatment will be
different.
Dr Dipak Shirude: I have
experience of some patients presenting as frozen shoulder but finally diagnosed
cardiac illness ( blockages ) and got relieved after successful treatment of
heart.
Vd. Dipam Tripathi: AGnikarm
gives wonder ful reault
Vd. Hardik J. Patel-
MD: Patra pinda upanaha swedan with arka, eranda, nirgundi on shoulder
joint if it has stiffness. Agnikarma with loha shalaka at tender point on
shoulder joint if pain. …..In classical text there is nasya of Bruhatmasha Taila.
…..According to charaka shada upakrama if stambha(stiffness) and shula (pain)
than swedan upakram is best way to get relief in this type of condition.
Vd. Jignesh Thakkar: In any vat
disease if we see before vat vyadhi vat gets vitated in kostha because of
ruksha and katu nature of food .vegavrodh etc then after it spreads in body and
where ever there is strotodusti(disturbed body chennel)it stays there and
causes vat disease. So we should use ….1)pachanam and anulomanam drug as base
line treatment…..2)abhang swedanam….3)vatsamak drugs.........If still problem
persist we should go fore basti karma….. If we use vatsamak oil etc
directly it is not going to work ..Anulomanam and pachanam is base line
treatment. then and then we should use guggulu preparations.
Vd. Dhruti Kagrana: Frozen
Shoulder:
Wholesome Diet and habits: 1. Warm
and unctuous food, 2. Proper and regular exercise, 3. Warm water bath loosens
the stiffness., Include anti inflammatory spices such as turmeric and black
pepper in diet.
Unwholesome Diet and habits: 1. Cold water bath, 2. Excess use of A/C
rooms, 3. Excess of oily and fried food, 4. Heavy exercise, 5. Improper laying,
sitting and sleeping position etc.
Bunty Gnadhi: I was
benefited a lot with two seating of agnikarma for my shoulder pain. Doctor ahas
diagnosed it as manyastambha. There was lot pain from neck to shoulder. 80%
improvement in pain after 2 seating. I was surprised….Recently my uncle with
shoulder pain and restricted movements, after allopathic treatment and physiotherapy
practice in which actually pain increased, went to govt ayurvedic hospital
where he was given basti karma with tila taila for 20 days…..With it he gets
much benefited in restricted movement of shoulder. Pain is still there as he
didnt took oral medicines he was given.
I had electric acupunctures for curing my shoulder pain and took 5 sessions at regular intervals. I think you must get an expert’s advice regarding this. I took it from one of reputed acupuncture Mississauga center who were known for this treatment.
ReplyDeleteI found good relief with fried garlic and ajwain in mustard oil and rubbing it many times. Also ashwaganda churna and physiotherapy enriched with magnetic fields. Also homeopathic bryonia 200ch once a day for 3 days.
ReplyDelete