Views shared by several ayurveda professionals and non-ayurveda people in discussion group:
All views shared here are only for knowledge. This information doesn’t have any scientific validation. Various doctors and non-medicos have shared their views and experiences in this discussion. Please do not try any of the suggestions described here, without prior consult from your regular, qualified doctor. Dr. Prerak Shah and no other person is responsible for any unwanted effects, side effects or contra-indications in your health. Thank you.
(Any ayurveda or medical doctor, If you like this activity, and wants to be a part of this chat discussion on whatsapp, please send in your request by email to email@example.com Thank you.)
Next topic for discussion: Understanding of Duodenitis and its management approach with #Ayurveda
Ayulink: Can we consider this condition as 'Grahani'? Duodenitis most common symptoms are vomit, nausea, discomfort in abdomen and many times gas trouble. That makes little difficult to interpret as 'Grahani'. Grahani disease is correlated with Irritable bowel syndrome, sprue, malabsorption syndrome. That makes this debate open for its understanding in #ayurvedic view point.
Dr. Pramod Nakarde: Pittaj grahani???
Ayulink offers Chemical Free Beauty Treatments
Ayulink offers Chemical Free Beauty Treatments
We recommend enjoying 2 hour Complete Body Polish Treatment in this marriage season to improve your personality…
Ayulink: Grahani defines a diseased condition, in which the integrity and the function of the small intestine (known as grahani in Sanskrit) is compromised. Grahani is the principal seat of agni… the digesrive fire. Normally, grahani holds up the meals, until it is digested and releases it from the site only, after digestion is over. But when the function of grahani is compromised due to weakness in the digestive fire, it releases the ingested material even in undigested conditions.
AYURVEDA DESCRIBES FOUR DIFFERENT TYPES OF GRAHANI.
Vata grahani (Malabsorption caused by vitiation of the biological air): In vata grahani, constipation is the predominant symptom.
Pitta grahani (Malabsorption caused by vitiation of the biological fire): In pitta grahani, diarrhea is the predominant symptom.
Kapha grahani (Malabsorption caused by vitiation of the biological water): In kapha grahani, dysentery is the predominant symptom.
Tridosha grahani: In this case, all the three biological humours are involved.
Other texts have mentioned two varieties of grahani accrual (samgraha grahani) (accrual malabsorption) and an incurable type called ghatiyanthra grahani (tympanitis predominant malabsorption). This has been described as sangrahini.
Dr. Piyush Dodiwadiya: I think grahni now a days consider as ulcerative colitis or irritable bowel syndrome. Sprue is very unlikely. In My 9 year carrier in ICU and allopathy hospital, I never seen patient diagnosed as a sprue.
Ayulink: GRAHANI SIGNS AND SYMPTOMS: Abdominal pain, Anaemia, Dehydration, Depression, Diarrhoea with fatty stools, Lethargy, Loss of weight
Dr. Piyush Dodiwadiya: Deodinitis can be taken as parinam shool
Ayulink: So this became more interesting to understand Duodinitis....???
Dr. Mrugeshkumar Patel: Deodenal ulcer become deodenitis then become structure of duodenum then reqar surgeory
Dr. Sushant Patil: A disorder characterized by abnormally increased motility of the small and large intestines, producing abdominal pain, constipation, or diarrhea, is also known as irritable colon, spastic colon, or mucous colitis. We can say and compare about Grahan like this. Ayurveda characterizes the disease by the passage of stools alternated with constipation or diarrhea and with undigested food particles. This disease is also associated with thirst, distaste, blackouts, pedal edema, pain in the bone, fever, and vomiting. It is a motility disorder involving the entire GI tract, causing recurring upper and lower GI symptoms, including variable degrees of abdominal pain, constipation and diarrhea, and abdominal bloating.
IBS is also associated with non gastrointestinal conditions such as headache, low back pain, arthritis, non cardiac chest pain, difficult urination, and fibromyalgia.
Ayulink: our question for today is how to interpret Duodenitis ? and its management according to Ayurveda. Until we have clearity in mind for any health condition, how can we suggest any management?
Vd. Pritam Bharat Veer: Duodenitis according to AYURVEDIC point of view is just about pitta prakop along with vat which may show symptoms like shul , daah , rag of internal lining of duodenum which we can corelate with Parinaam shul also. Treatment given according to me us pittashamak like avipattikar , dhatri , duralabha , kamdudha , praval etc.
Ayulink: Usually 'itis' means inflammation or swelling...here Duodenitis means inflammation of duodenum? Can we consider as Grahani shoth? But the first question is Duodenum = Grahani?
Shri Minoo parabia: Mostly it is triggered either by some infection , crohn's or by aspirin like medicine or by bile reflux. My experience is , freshly dicocted Panchvalka kadha + pittashamak, cures the problem. Helicobacter pylori is the culprit in most of the cases.
Dr Jayesh Patel: Yes we consider duodenum as grahani.......
Vd. Dhruti Kagrana: Our Aacharya consider grahni also as Agni. So grahni is not only duodenum. But we also include liver, gallbladder, pancreas etc in the world Grahni.
Ayulink: That may be true. Our main objective is to understand deodinitis, not Grahani. Duodenum is clearly defined in modern science. Plus inflammation of Duodenum is deodinitis. But the symptoms arise in that condition are completely different then Grahani. That's main objective of this discussion. Thnx
Dr. Sushant Patil: I have a doubt that How can we compare A modern terminology in Ayurved Text. See We don't have name for many diseases in our old text separately. We can give medicine on Dosh samuchhyaya and sthana of Dosh. It's wrong if we diagnose as per modern terminology and think to give as per Ayurved aspect.
Ayulink: Thank you for this note. That is exactly the idea is, Main objective is to understand Duodenitis. We do not want to label it in ayurveda ways. Also we do not want to mix up with our terminology. I do agree that we are capable of offering asymptomatic treatment for this. Many choices are with us to control symptoms such as vomit, nausea, discomfort in abdomen and many times gas trouble. (Lakshnik chikitsa). But the question still stands remain there, Understanding the pathology / etiology of such symptoms which can lead us to stop recurring complains.
Vd. Jayesh Thakkar: Yes agree with above. Have found Praval panchamrit, Punarnavadi mandoor, Manibhadra lehyam helpful in such condition.
Dr. Dayanand Bothre: Since grahani is chronic condition where dominantly pitta dosh vitiated and intenstine also gets weak ( abalatwa) hence after dipan pachan of aam by aampachak vati we use ghrut for vitiated pitta and to strengthen the intenstine and for healing also
In ashtang hrudya there is shatavari ghrut which is find better
Compiled by: Vd. Dhruti Kagrana